Poppy's Bagels

Ohhh Poppy's, there are so many good things to praise this local business for- good food with an abundance of protein in each sandwich, but the customer service? The way everyone is so welcoming? Everytime I happen to visit, the owners and the staff are so sweet. The vibes at this spot are honestly just right. It feels nice to have good interactions and good food. ps, I love the Lox n schmear!!

So happy this location is even closer to my house! Tried the mama bagel today soo delicious, perfect for when craving something simple. As always strawberry matcha latte was to die for.

Love poppy’s Conestoga as much as the uptown location!! Super consistent with their service; everything tastes the same and the staff is just as great as in uptown. The bagels taste just as yummy and fresh, the sandwiches as usual are super filling and delicious and the drinks are sooooo good. Would definitely recommend if you haven’t tried it yet. It’s also really nice to be able to support a small local family business in a big mall like Conestoga, and there’s basically infinite seating since it’s in the food court.

As someone who is an avid bagel lover, I was a little disappointed with this bagel shop. I ordered the lox, and for the price, I expected a more generous portion of salmon. I asked for the bagel to be toasted, but it arrived quite underdone. The bagel itself wasn’t bad, and the staff was friendly, which I appreciated. It did take a while to get my order, but the service was pleasant overall. I’d be open to coming back, trying something else on the menu, and asking for the bagel to be double toasted.

Highly recommend the "big tuna" bagel sandwich. I love that they are accommodating in terms of removing things of the sandwich you don't want. Prices are a little hefty but it's a nice treat once in a while and the food is filling. Service was good, a couple issues processing a gift card but it was no big deal . I like that they strictly make sure it's obvious you won't be getting your food as quick as a fast food place like Tim's but in fact since everything is made fresh, it's going to take a little bit. Try this place out!

The perfect place for a bagel shop with the most amazing bagel I’ve had in my life. The worker named Oliver was incredibly friendly and helpful and the mall is a great location for a smaller business like this. The Kyrie is a must-have, and I’ve already gotten it twice, and will continue to do so in the future!

Poppy’s Bagels is me and my roommate's absolute favorite go-to spot — we’re so excited there's a location at the mall now! It makes our shopping trips 100x better knowing we can stop by for the best bagels around. The Kyrie bagel is our fave (seriously, if you haven’t tried it, you're missing out), and nothing hits quite like an iced strawberry matcha to go with it. Shoutout to Mila, who was super helpful with our order and made one of the best matchas we’ve had. Love the vibes, love the bagels, and love having Poppy’s as part of our mall routine.

Holy it was scrumptious ! I got the Mama “Classic” which is a blueberry bagel with a strawberry schmear (strawberry cream cheese). I got chips and a strawberry matcha drink. Absolutely what I needed. I thought a strawberry smear would have been jam but wow, pleasantly surprised. Love that this is local. Going to have to come around these parts more often!